Huan (Harry) Wang · Research
← All papers

For dignity or honor: The effects of Kantian and utilitarian duty orientations on third-party responses to abusive supervision

Wang, H. (2024). Doctoral dissertation, Rutgers University, Graduate School-Newark. doi:10.7282/t3-5ga4-y538

Abstract

Research has shown that third parties' sense of duty can explain their reactions to the abusive supervision of coworkers, where duty has been theorized as a general concept to contrast with instrumental explanations of moral behaviors. Recently, researchers started investigating different duty orientations in organizations, including one's perceived duty to organizational members, missions, and codes. This dissertation argues that such conceptualization of duty has primarily focused on Utilitarian duty orientation (UDO). In contrast, moral duty orientations in the deontological tradition, particularly Kantian ethics, were missing. Drawn from Kant's discussion on the duty to not disrespect others, this dissertation proposed a new construct termed Kantian duty orientation (KDO), defined as the employees' volition to refrain from disrespecting others. Based on individual differences in duty orientations, I construct a model that contrasts the effects of Kantian-based and Utilitarian-based duty orientations on the perception of observed abusive supervision and the subsequent emotions (anger and empathy) and behaviors (supervisor deviance and coworker support). Study 1 documents the development of the Kantian Duty Orientation (KDO) scale, with results supporting its initial reliability and validity. Studies 2 and 3 (N=503 and 390) tested the theoretical model by contrasting the effects of KDO and UDO. The results from both field survey studies indicate a negative relationship between the two duty orientations and observed abusive supervision, which, in turn, leads to negative relationships with emotional and behavioral responses. This dissertation highlights how moral duty shapes the complex interactions among third parties, victims, and aggressors in organizational settings. In the interest of establishing moral motives, previous third-party studies have generally assumed or created situations in which the third party has little stake in what they observe, thereby making standing up to the aggressor less challenging. Since both KDO and UDO are deeply situated in organizations, the complex relationships that the third party has with the aggressor and the victim may account for these results. This argument is consistent with the theory and research on organizational silence and the challenges of promoting voice in organizations. The dissertation's limitations, future research directions, and theoretical and practical implications were also discussed.

How to cite

Wang, H. (2024). For dignity or honor: The effects of Kantian and utilitarian duty orientations on third-party responses to abusive supervision. Doctoral dissertation, Rutgers University, Graduate School-Newark. https://doi.org/10.7282/t3-5ga4-y538

The DOI is the permanent address of this work; this page is the author's own copy.